top of page
Writer's pictureRuina

The Archetypes of Red Rose, White Rose.

I need to balance my brain out due to sudden onset of depression. It is the result. Rommel is probably the only general who, even if you draw him from the back, he’s still recognizable- flowers, a camera, and love for beauty. Rommel has a Venus-Mercury conjunct with a direct Neptune influence; he is going to appreciate artistic expressions.



In fact, this colored-doodle with an unintentional Mucha vibe has the energy of his wife Lucy in mind. According to some sources, Rommel wrote home to Lucy daily, as it was reported to be his mental crutch- I imagine it to be transcendental emotional support, not unlike my own experience, my own relationship with our Tumblr community here. Whether you guys interact with me directly or not, you keep me alive. My sincere thanks to you.


Lucy was a formal dancer in Danzig with a decent middle-class background, her father seemed to be a land owner- Lucy being able to do art, probably added to his admiration for her- fellow artists, angelic companionship.


I suppose he did need emotional supports, and a lot of it– Rommel is the only high commander with whom Kessering “the smiling Albert” did not get along– which is a feat. After all, Kessering was very renowned for his exceedingly cordial and diplomatic temperament. The same could be said of von Rundstedt, the calm, gentlemanly, old Prussian field marshal. These two could put up with some bad BS from any one else, except Rommel. He was too intense, too mentally off-balance, too difficult to deal with for his colleagues.



There are a few things I noticed from Rommel’s biography (including the Trail of the Fox, 2005), that allow me to make some observations. His love for Lucy appears to be non-sexual. They had their only son 12 years after marriage. That is a pretty long time, not customary with a Scorpio man who has a 8th house Mars (who is supposed to have at least above average sex drive).


As a matter of fact, Rommel had a daughter with Walburga Stemmer before his marriage with Lucy was finalized. At that point Rommel’s family felt the need to step in and strong-armed him back with his fiancée– one reason being to prevent the young lieutenant from the pitfalls of sex and alcohol. In my humble opinion, the subtext here might be Lucy would not lead him astray in that regard, therefore his conservative family would rather have him marrying Lucy.


A side note, Stemmer family still holds a collection of hopelessly romantic letters from Rommel. Did Rommel write comparable letters to Lucy at that point in time? A bit hard to tell.



I could not recall which article comments that Rommel was “hen-pecked’ in the household, but Lucy was dominant at home, that part had been very true.



Ouch, I don’t know, some aspects of this living environment must’ve been toxic to Rommel no matter how much some folks wants to romanticize it. It is horrible to be in a friend group where there’s a mean girl boss who takes pride in ruling over her husband and turning any girl who crosses her into a persona-non-grata. But I digress. Back to my title.


Nevertheless, for me, Lucy being archetypal White Rose still holds water as a concept.




The Red Rose- White Rose archetypes originated from the same-titled short novel by Zhang Ailing, one of the 20th century’s greatest female writers. She depicts love’s tragedies as Chin dynasty fell apart and China marched into an era of post-colonialism, world war II, civil wars and partisan conflicts– and eventually, modernity.


White rose is your ideal wife, the guardian of your family’s social standing. She is angelic, she seems docile, she reminds you that you are from a place of honor and integrity, not of seedy backgrounds and carnal desires. White rose kills love by loving you, by being stable, by calming you down whenever you freak out. Very slowly, she castrates you, she brings you home to domesticate you.


The Red Rose symbolizes those dark desires, a black hole that sucks you in to have sex with you, a fragrant bed, a sex dungeon you do not have the will power to claw yourself out of. Red rose loves you by conquering you, destroying you and everything you represent and cherish with triumphant strides. Very quickly Red rose tears you down, burns all your bridges, until you are beyond recognition, until you are flesh, blood, fire and desire, a literal mess.



It is implied in Ailing’s novel that men invariably choose the White Rose, because they are human, all too human. Marrying her, he regrets it; not marrying her, he regrets it even more. Such is love’s tragedy in the face of humanity, and tragedy is the only inevitability in Ailing’s universe. That’s why I pull Lucy in as a faint through-line in my Montgomery x Rommel fanfics… not that I am going to write any more, I don’t think so.


And yes, Red Rose is synonymous with Bernard Montgomery, in my fandom brain’s humble opinion.


I know I am weird.

28 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page